If one were to search, they'd be hard-pressed to find an anime fan who hasn't seen Hayao Miyazaki's classic film Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind, but fans who haven't read the manga are without question missing a lot. The film is like an appetizer, if you will - it readies the palate in preparation for the main course. Of course, one doesn't have to see the movie first to fully appreciate the manga, but the manga certainly shines better if the movie is seen first. Just like how an appetizer enhances the flavor of the main course.The storyline in the film basically only covers events from the first couple of volumes. Though it incorporates the same environment message and themes, the manga is far more fleshed out, more sprawling environment epic. Plus, the film had to remove certain subplots that had yet to be fully realized in the manga at the time. Basically, Miyazaki tweaked his unfinished story quite a bit when he adapted into an animated film. If he had waited until the 1990s to adapt Nausicaä, he certainly would have needed to make more than one film, since condensing the story at that point would have been impractical, as the story spans 900-plus pages in seven oversized volumes.
From the perspective of the film's ending, that was really only the beginning as far as the manga is concerned. It really begins to take off there as Nausicaä moves on to investigate the meaning behind the message of the Ohmu. There's plenty more to be encountered. Immortals, political upheaval, astral projection, a failed experiment with mold takes a shocking turn for the worst, a child-like God Warrior, etc. Miyazaki's creative vision is fully realized here, and his cautionary message is certainly thought-provoking. It's a bit grim when it all comes down to it, but all the more uplifting when one digs deep and fully realizes the layer of hope underneath.
One can criticize Miyazaki's artwork as being a bit odd, since it takes a some time to get used to. Seeing him depict things using still frames versus animation takes a bit of an adjustment, and sometimes the panel-to-panel flow can be a little awkward in the early volumes. Eventually, though, Miyazaki was able to improve his paneling to the point where it's much more straightfoward and easier to read. This then causes the artwork to shine more brightly. Speaking of which, his art itself is certainly gorgeous to look at, as it is lavishly detailed, but sometimes it gets bogged down in its own detail. Many times there's a so much happening in a panel that it becomes difficult to distinguish what exactly is going on. This is a problem many manga artists face, and seeing even the great Miyazaki struggle with it is somewhat refreshing. Also, the art gets obstructed by word bubbles quite often when there's a lot of expository dialogue, but this is something that one will find in just about any comic. To really delve any deeper would be to nitpick. As a whole, the book is a feast for the eyes from start to finish.
Nausicaä is Miyazaki's finest work -- his life's greatest masterpiece -- be it print on animation in every way imaginable. It's a darn shame that the film doesn't do the manga justice. Still, if one considers that it took Miyazaki over 12 years to complete the story and then reminicises on the strengths of the film -- such as its ending -- it's easier to appriecate the film for what it is. That doesn't change the fact that reading the manga is an absolute necessity if one wants the fully realized tale.
Overall:
(out of 5)Story:

Art:

10 comments:
"The film is like an appetizer, if you will - it readies the palate in preparation for the main course." You have been reading "Oishinbo" manga haven't you?
Ho .... now then--now why would you--why would you say something like THAT? I, uh, I have never, uh, read such a book as an "Oishinbo"; but, uhhhh, if I had I'm sure it would look and sound COMPLETELY different.
I've been wanting to read the manga series ever since I heard there was one in the first place, and it's great to know how well worth it it is. Nausica along with Princess Monnonoke have always traded blows as being my all time favorite anime movie and one of my all time favorite movies altogether (though I've decided in the last year or so to give that title to Nausica), so that's really saying something that the manga is that much better. Any idea where I might be able to find it by any chance?
You can order the series from Right Stuf, though not all volumes are in stock at the moment.
I gocha. I also found all 7 volumes over on Amazon as well that I could buy used for a grand total of around $40 or so, taking the conditions of the books into consideration and everything of course.
Only $40? Very nice! That's a steal.
Of course that's if you're willing to look past the fact that they're used and therefore aren't always in the best of conditions. But the way I see it as long as I can still read them and still get into the story well enough that's all that really matters.
One thing I didn't mention in the review: Given how much better the manga is, I lowered by ANN rating for the movie from "Masterpiece" to "Very Good." Of course, I gave the manga the rating of "Masterpiece."
That should give a pretty good idea of how much better I found the manga to be in relation to the film.
Yeah, even though typically I usually do that myself, chances are I probably won't this time, no matter how much better the manga is. Kind of a nostalgia sort of thing, you know?
Yeah, understand completely. I just couldn't in my right mind leave them both rated the same when one was so much better than the other.
Post a Comment
Got something to say? Then post it, darn you!